On hiatus since 2018.

2017

Game of the Year: The Watch

2016

Game of the Year: Blades in the Dark (2017)

2015

Game of the Year: Night Witches

2014

Game of the Year: The Clay that Woke

2013

Game of the Year: Hillfolk

2012

Game of the Year: Dungeon World (2012)

2011

Game of the Year: Do - Pilgrims of the Flying Temple

2010

Game of the Year: Apocalypse World

2009

Game of the Year: Kagematsu

2008

Game of the Year: Mouse Guard

2007

Game of the Year: Grey Ranks

2006

Game of the Year: Spirit of the Century (2006)

2005

Game of the Year: Polaris

2004

Game of the Year: Dogs in the Vineyard (2004)

2003

Game of the Year: FATE 2e (2003)

2002

Game of the Year: Dust Devils