On hiatus since 2018.
2017
Game of the Year: The Watch
2016
Game of the Year: Blades in the Dark (2017)
2015
Game of the Year: Night Witches
2014
Game of the Year: The Clay that Woke
2013
Game of the Year: Hillfolk
2012
Game of the Year: Dungeon World (2012)
2011
Game of the Year: Do - Pilgrims of the Flying Temple
2010
Game of the Year: Apocalypse World
2009
Game of the Year: Kagematsu
2008
Game of the Year: Mouse Guard
2007
Game of the Year: Grey Ranks
2006
Game of the Year: Spirit of the Century (2006)
2005
Game of the Year: Polaris
2004
Game of the Year: Dogs in the Vineyard (2004)
2003
Game of the Year: FATE 2e (2003)
2002
Game of the Year: Dust Devils